
Corporate Cultures
Casino Babel
by Ray Knight and Rob Sanders
Communication is the lifeline that ties a corporate culture together.
Communication connects management to employees, departments with other
departments, and employees to one another. When there's a break in
the lifeline, someone is cast adrift and isolated from the culture.
In many casinos, whole groups of employees are severed from the
communication lifeline by the simple fact of language. They speak
little or no English. Yet English is almost always the language used
in the meetings they attend and the memos they get. They have no
idea what's going on and muddle through the best they can, often feeling
uncertain and excluded from the culture.
Labor is tight. Casinos have found it very difficult to
fill out their staffs, especially in the less glamorous back-of-the-house
jobs. Immigrants are eager to work and willing to take the entry-level
positions to get a foothold in America. Sometimes that means modifying
standards to fill the vacancies.
But there's a catch to it. If you expect them to do things
your way, you have to let them know what you have in mind. You can't
expect them to understand if you speak to them only in English.
"Many of them don't even look at memos, because they can't read
them," said Sonia Balart. Balart is a translator and research interviewer
for The Discovery Group. A native-born Cuban, she conducts employee
focus groups in Spanish.
She described an Hispanic chef's helper with minimal command
of English who made the same dish the same way every day for two years,
as instructed. One day he was preparing the dish as usual, and the
chef reprimanded him severely. There had been a menu change.
"I posted the memo on the bulletin board yesterday...didn't you see it?"
the chef bellowed. The memo was in English.
Balart has found that employees whose English is sparse will
often avoid communicating. "They fear that if their supervisors know
how little English they know, they'll lose their jobs. They communicate
as little as possible so as not to get caught." They appreciate having
the job, but feel segregated from the rest of the culture. They tend
to huddle together in a sub-culture of their own language.
Grand Victoria Casino in Elgin, Illinois, a Mandalay Resort Group
property, attacks the language barrier head-on. The Chicago-area
casino draws from a polyglot workforce that includes a large Hispanic (primarily
Mexican) population, along with Laotian, Central European, and Scandinavian.
About 30 percent of the Grand Victoria staff is Hispanic. Eighty
percent of the kitchen staff is Spanish-speaking.
Sharon McGill, Director of Human Resources, explained that with
labor so tight, the casino was continually short in certain positions,
especially in the entry-level, back-of-the-house jobs. The company
found that there were people in the community willing to work but couldn't
meet the literacy and English requirements. "We relaxed the requirements
for some positions where it was not essential to job performance."
McGill believes it's important to bring these employees into
the cultural mainstream of the casino "but have respect for their native
language." About half the Human Resources staff at Grand Victoria
is bilingual. McGill has also arranged with a local community college
to have Spanish-speaking employees attend English-as-a-second-language
courses. "English is a difficult language to learn. It's hard
for first-generation immigrants. But this is a first step toward
assimilation. The second generation usually adapts to English more
easily."
Food and Beverage Manager Fred Pearson said memos about mandatory
issues are sometimes translated into Spanish using a computer program.
Some Spanish-only meetings are conducted. "We're also fortunate in
that we have people in supervisory roles and employees who are bilingual
who help communicate to those who are not."
Hispanics are the fastest-growing demographic segment in America.
Pearson believes it will increasingly be a big advantage for casino executives
to be bilingual. He recommends having at least a conversational grasp
of Spanish.
Grand Victoria's General Manager, Pete Dominguez, who is Hispanic,
helps bridge the language gap. He has high regard for his Spanish-speaking
employees. "They have a great work ethic. And they're very
reliable; they show up." He regular circulates among the Spanish-speaking
staff, and they respond positively to hearing him speak to them in their
own language. He instructed department heads to translate operating
manuals and employee handbooks into Spanish.
The Grand Victoria's efforts to overcome segregation by language
gets a thumbs up from Mandalay Resort Group. Chris Mortell, Divisional
Director of Training and Internal Marketing, said the assimilation and
integration of non-English-speaking employees is essential. "It's
not a matter of should, but how."
Mortell notes that language segregation is a challenge for gaming
cultures all over the country. "In Tunica, for example, we have a
large number of French-speaking West Africans."
There are some who may say, "Well, in America we speak English,
and if they want to work, they should learn our language." True.
But it has taken most of us a lifetime to learn English well. If
you're going to hire them, it's up to you to give non-English-speaking
employees a chance to become full-fledged members of your culture by making
sure your communication lifeline reaches them.
(This article appeared in the November 2000 issue.)
(Top) |